Revenue Conference Report $7 million Less than Proposed Revenue Package Earlier this Week

The revenue conference report signed by the House and Senate this afternoon will provide less revenue than was previously proposed earlier this week.

The revenue conference report provides $794.1 million in new revenue ($667.7 million +$126.4 million cigarette tax). This is over $7 million less than the $801.3 million proposed in the revenue agreement discussed this past week.

So what is different?

  • Minimum Nexus Standards ($84.7 million). Incorporates all changes from Senate and House. In addition, includes a B&O deduction for interest and fees on loans secured by commercial aircraft. Effective June 1, 2010.
  • Tax Avoidance Transactions ($8.5 million). Provides the Washington Department of Revenue authority to disregard three specific types of tax avoidance transactions. Creates legislative oversight committee. Effective May 1, 2010.
  • Homestreet Fix (modifying first mortgage deduction) ($3.6 million). Servicing of loans by the originator of the loans qualifies for the deduction; other types of fees and charges are not deductible. Effective June 1, 2010.
  • Livestock nutrients (sales tax exemption for livestock nutrient equipment and facilities) ($1.3 million). Changes effective date to July 1, 2010 from April 1, 2010.
  • Corporate Directors B&O (B&O tax on corporate directors) ($2.1 million). Changes effective date to July 1, 2010 from April 1, 2010.
  • Sales and use tax applied to bottled water ($35.3 million). From June 1, 2010 to June 30, 2010 bottled water is subject to sales and use tax. The exemptions for prescribed water and for persons without potable water are made in the form of a refund except for bulk deliveries.
  • Sales tax applied to candy and gum ($30.5 million). Candy and gum are subject to sales tax, as of June 1, 2010. Provides a job credit of $1,000 per position for the next two years for candy manufacturers. Washington Department of Revenue will publish a list of taxable candy, if not on the list, retailers must check with Revenue.
  • PUD privilege tax clarification ($1.2 million). Changes effective date to May 1, 2010 from June 1 in the Senate and April 1 in the House.
  • Temporary B&O tax surcharge on service businesses ($241.9 million). Temporary B&O surcharge of 0.3% from May 1, 2010 to June 30, 2013. Permanently doubles the small business tax credit for service businesses. Excludes public and private hospitals as well as certain R&D activities.
  • Property management B&O (limits the B&O exemption for property management salaries) ($6.9 million). The exemption is not repealed but rather is limited to nonprofit property management companies and property management companies that contract with a housing authority. Effective June 1, 2010.
  • Temporary Beer Tax increase ($59. million). From June 1, 2010 to June 30, 2013 increases the Beer Tax by 50 cents per gallon (28 cent increase for six packs). The temporary increase does not apply to the first 60,000 barrels produced by small breweries
  • Temporary soda/pop tax increase ($33.5 million). Beginning July 1, 2010 to June 30, 2013 increases the tax on carbonated beverages (pop/soda) by 2 cents per 12 oz bottle. The first $10 million in sales is exempt from the tax increase.

Here is what did not change.

  • DOT Foods (direct seller B&O exemption) ($155 million).  Effective  May 1, 2010. 
  • Agrilink (B&O tax on manufacturing of certain agricultural products) ($4.1 million).  Effective May 1, 2010.
  • Tax debts corp (tax debts – corporate officer liability)($1.1 million)
  • Bad debt (limits the bad debt deductions) ($1.7 million)

And finally, here is what was not included in the conference report.

  • Changing the definition of “qualifying business”, regarding data centers, so that a lessee of a least 20,000 sq. ft. of space within an eligible computer data center can qualify for the exemption. Amends the job provisions to provide associated definitions regarding the requirement to increase employment by 35 family wage jobs.
  • Limiting the foreclosure exemption from the Real Estate Excise Tax (REET).
  • Repealing the B&O tax job credit for international service activities.
  • Changing the rural county tax incentive to allow for claims for incentives for computer programming only when it is used to create a new item for sale.
  • Limiting the B&O deduction for dues and initiation fees.
  • Repealing the sales tax exemption for coal used at a coal-fired thermal electric generation facility.
  • Changing the exemption for machinery used to create electricity and wind to require a producer to either be a local utility or someone contracting with a local utility for the sale of power.
  • Establishing the temporary 0.2% slaes and use tax and Working Families Tax Credit.
  • Repealing the nonresident sales tax exemption
  • Establishing an aircraft excise tax.
  • Capping the first mortgage interest deduction at $120 million.
  • Extending sales tax to custom software
  • Eliminating the credit against the sales tax for the Convention Center.

Revenue Conference Report Signed but Still Counting Votes

Early this afternoon members of the conference committee for Senate Bill 6143 (the revenue bill) met and signed the revenue conference report – $794.1 million in revenue.

Senators Murray and Prentice and Representatives Hunter and Hasegawa received a summary of the conference report from staff prior to signing the report.  Democrats took the opportunity offered by the conference report signing to underline the importance of new revenue to protect public services.

Both chambers also shared that vote counting on the revenue package is continuing.  When asked by the media if there are votes in the House and Senate to approve this compromise, Senator Murray, Democratic Caucus Chair, said “We’re confident but we’re counting votes.”  Similar thoughts were echoed by House Finance Chair, Representative Ross Hunter, “I think we’re very close. I think we’re closer than we were yesterday.”

At the same time the House and Senate continue to count revenue votes, negotiations on the operating and capital budgets continue. As shared by Senator Margarita Prentice, Chair of the Senate Ways & Means Committee,  “We’re still working,” when asked about negotiations on the actual budget.

The revenue conference report would provide the state with $794.1 million in new revenue.

Conference Revenue Report
($794.1 million)

  • Temporary Services B&O surcharge to 1.8% without hospitals and narrow exemption for R&D. Small business credit doubled (credit permanent). Effective May 1, 2010 and expires June 30, 2013 ($241.9 million).
  • Temporary Beer Tax increase of 50 cents per gallon. Twenty-eight cent increase per six pack. Microbreweries exempt. Effective June 1, 2010 and expires June 30, 2013 ($59 million).
  • Temporary soda/pop tax increase of 2 cents per 12 oz bottle. Bottlers under $10 million in volume exempt. Effective July 1, 2010 and expires June 30, 2013 ($33.5 million).
  • Dot Foods ($155 million).
  • Cigarettes and other tobacco products (House Bill 2493) ($101.4 million).
  • Nexus ($84.7 million).
  • Sales and use tax applied to bottled water. Exemption for prescription water and unavailable potable water ($32.6 million).
  • Sales tax applied to candy and gum. B&O credit for jobs ($30.5 million).
  • Lottery Marketing (Senate Bill 6409) ($15 million).
  • Convention Center (Senate Bill 6889– Delivered to the Governor) ($10 million).
  • Tax avoidance ($8.5 million).
  • Property management. B&O ($6.9 million).
  • Agrilink ($4.1 million).
  • Homestreet fix ($3.6 million).
  • Corp. Dir. B& O ($2.1 million).
  • Bad debt ($1.7 million).
  • Livestock nutrients ($1.3 million).
  • PUD clarification ($1.1 million).
  • Tax debts corp ($1.2 million).

The conference report must sit on the bar of both the House and Senate for a full day before it can be voted upon. The report can only be voted up or down without amendment. The House will take up the package first, likely tomorrow.

No Declared Agreement. Floor Sessions Scheduled for Saturday

No official announcement has been released at this time regarding a final agreement on revenue by the Legislature. The new revenue package released earlier this week is still being considered by both Chambers and votes are being counted.

Though no progress has been made to seal the deal with regard to revenue since the last blog posting, there is some hope that tomorrow’s scheduled floor action at 2:00 p.m. for both Chambers will be the necessary first step to a successful sine die of special session.

Next week, Tuesday, April 13, will mark the end of the first special session of 2010, final revenue package and budgets or not.

No Agreement Yet…But Here is What All the Buzz is About

This week the House and Senate have been busy exchanging revenue proposals and counter-proposals.  Though no agreement has been reached between the two chambers, details of the single revenue package that is being shared among members of both the House and Senate have been revealed.

The current revenue package being discussed by all on The Hill does not include a sales tax or a a tax on software. In addition the package would continue exemptions on first mortgage interest income and out-of-state shoppers.

Further examination shows that three of the proposed provisions are temporary and expire in 2013. These include the B&O surcharge on most service businesses, the beer tax increase, and the soda/pop tax increase. To protect small service businesses, the B&O surcharge includes a doubling of the small business tax credit. Small businesses with gross sales up to about $56K will be exempt and those making up to about $80K will pay less. None of Washington’s breweries should be impacted by the beer tax increase since microbreweries will continue paying the same tax. Finally, a B&O tax credit for jobs at Washington’s candy manufacturers will likely buffer them from any negative impact of the candy sales tax.

Current Revenue Proposal
($801.3 million)

  • Temporary Services B&O surcharge to 1.8% without hospitals. Small business credit doubled. Effective May 1, 2010 and expires June 30, 2013 ($245.9 million)
  • Temporary Beer Tax increase of 50 cents per gallon. Microbreweries exempt. Effective June 1, 2010 and expires June 30, 2013 ($57.8 million)
  • Temporary soda/pop tax increase of 2 cents per 12 oz. Bottlers under $10 million in volume exempt. Effective July 1, 2010 and expires June 30, 2013 ($38.1 million)
  • Dot Foods ($154.7 million)
  • Cigarettes and other tobacco products (House Bill 2493) ($101.4 million)
  • Nexus ($82.4 million)
  • Sales and use tax applied to bottled water ($35.3 million)
  • Sales tax applied to candy and gum. B&O credit for jobs ($29 million)
  • Lottery Marketing (Senate Bill 6409) ($15 million)
  • Convention Center (Senate Bill 6889– Delivered to the Governor) ($10 million)
  • Tax avoidance ($8.2 million)
  • Property management. B&O ($6.9 million)
  • Agrilink ($4.1 million)
  • Homestreet fix ($3.9 million)
  • Corp. Dir. B& O ($2.1 million)
  • Bad debt ($1.7 million)
  • Livestock nutrients ($1.5 million)
  • PUD clarification ($1.2 million)
  • Tax debts corp ($1.1 million)
  • B&O dues ($1 million)

Both chambers hope to announce an agreement or disagreement sometime today with regard to the current proposed revenue package.

Over the weekend and through Tuesday, the Senate and House will need to pass a revenue package and operating and capital budgets, as well as, take action on various bills necessary to implement revenue and/or the budget, including the cigarette tax (HB 2493) which has passed the House and is now in the Senate; the lottery bill (SB 6409) which has passed the Senate and awaits action by the House; and finally perhaps take action on Senate Bill 6503 which would require state agencies to take a portion of their cuts in compensation related actions.

A Flurry of Action Over Revenue…Counting Votes

Though no final revenue agreement has been reached, a flurry of activity between the House and Senate leadership has taken place in efforts to find common ground.

The Senate and House both held Pro Forma sessions today and are expected to hold Pro Forma sessions tomorrow. Though most of the members are away from Olympia,  Senate and House leadership have met multiple times over the last few days to review and exchange offers on a revenue package. In addition, leadership from both chambers have met together with the Governor.

The details of the negotiations over revenue are being held close to the vest as the 30-day deadline for the first special session nears. However, one critical piece of information that has been confirmed is that the Senate has officially removed a plan to temporarily increase the sales tax from current negotiations.

At this time, each chamber is meeting with their respective members regarding the latest proposal in negotiations. If sufficient votes can be counted in favor of a negotiated package, it is possible that the Legislature will be able to conclude the first special session by Tuesday, April 13 the official deadline.

House Tweaks Revenue Proposal…Members and Senate Review

Earlier this week, the Senate released a new revenue package. Yesterday, Finance Chair Ross Hunter announced the House has a slightly-tweaked counter-proposal.

The changes that the House is proposing have not been shared. Representative Hunter did note that the House tweaked version of the Senate’s revenue proposal was presented to House members last night.  In addition, House and Senate leadership were also scheduled to talk last night regarding revenue.

At the time of this post,  the Senate has yet to voice any support or concern on the changes proposed by the House.

The revised package proposed by the Senate further reduces the sales tax increase from two-tenths of 1 percent to one-tenth of one percent and retains the Working Family Tax Rebate. In addition, the new proposal increases the existing tax on beer to 50 cents per gallon; beer with micro-brews exempted, and extends the sales tax to candy and gum with in-state producers getting a jobs tax credit. Finally, the new proposal includes the House’s proposal to raise taxes on all tobacco products, not just cigarettes.

The Senate and House are scheduled for Pro Forma sessions today and tomorrow, Thursday, April 8.  Both chambers are scheduled for floor action and caucus on Friday, April 9.

Revenue Deal Reached…We Think

This morning it was reported that the House and Senate have reached a deal on a tax package of $800 million to close the $2.8 billion state budget gap. 

Specific details are not available, but it is anticipated that the final deal will not include the temporary sales tax included in the Senate’s proposed revenue package.

It will take several days to draft the bill, run the numbers, and print documents. With that in mind a vote is not expected until mid-week next week or later.

On the Seventeenth Day there was Movement on the Horizon

This week has been a quiet one at the Capital.  Both the House and Senate have held “Pro Forma” sessions (no action) since Monday. Beginning tomorrow that is expected to change.

The Senate will come in on Thursday, April 1 (hopefully not an April Fool’s joke) to take action on a few remaining bills in order to move them to the House.  The House is expected to come in for floor action on Friday, April 2 to approve the bills the Senate moved over.

Negotiations continue to take place with regard to the supplemental budgets and possible revenue, with revenue continuing to be the major point of contention.

Last week Governor Gregoire suggested that a compromise may be to reduce the revenue package to $700 million. This would require either lowering the state’s ending fund balance or spending in the overall budget. The Senate strongly rejected both ideas.

In order to continue to move forward, last Friday, Sen. Brown (Senate Majority Leader) indicated in a press conference that she is beginning to discuss the possibility of finding something other than the sales tax that would fill the $200 million revenue gap that remains between the House and Senate. The other $600 million, noting the revenue target is $800 million, has been pretty much agreed upon (i.e. closing loopholes, using one-time funds, increasing the cigarette tax).

In response to Senator Brown’s comment, Senate budget writers spent this past weekend combing through a huge list of current tax exemptions looking for the elusive solution to end this special session.

It may appear that this hard work is paying off. Word on the street has it that the Senate and House will work this Thursday and Friday and perhaps the weekend and, if necessary, return April 9 to wrap up the special session by April 13 (the 30-day deadline).

Stay tuned…

The Beginning of Week Three

While many of us on Evergreen’s campus consider today the first day of spring term, for those of us with a foot in the legislative arena it also marks the first day of week three of the first special session of 2010. Is there any end in sight?

Negotiations continue on the 2010 supplemental operating and capital budgets. Though no agreements on either budget have been finalized, the issue  that has kept legislators in Olympia 15 days beyond the end of the regular session is revenue. More specifically, the sales tax and whether to increase the sales tax or not. The Senate is in favor and the House and Governor are not.

On Friday, some suggested that the Senate’s decision to move Senate Bill 6143 (revenue bill) to conference may be a small and optimistic sign towards the passage of a supplemental budget.  Optimism continued to rise, when later that day in a press conference Sen. Brown eluded to looking for $200 million in taxes to replace the Senate’s proposed sales tax increase. The source of these taxes was not made clear.

Both of these moves may lead one to be more optimistic than even 48 hours ago. However, there are still many in the Senate who support a sales tax and have concerns with regard to the business tax increases, proposed by the House, that are still in the mix.

As for now, the bills needed to implement a 2010 supplemental operating budget, 2010 supplemental capital budget, and increase revenue remain where they were at the end of last week. In addition, the bills that Evergreen is tracking this special session also have not moved further in the process.

Day Twelve of Special Session; Nearing End of Week 2

Yesterday was the first time since Monday that the Senate floor was active. Most Senators returned to Olympia for a brief floor session to concur on a handful of House bills. The House did not take any floor action.

Of most interest was the action the Senate took on Senate Bill 6143 (revenue tax bill). The Senate rejected the House’s amendments to SB 6143 and formally asked for an official Conference Committee.

In the meantime, the leadership of both chambers continue behind-the-scenes negotiations on a tax package to fund the 2010 supplemental operating budget and take action on a 2010 supplemental capital budget.

Lawmakers remain deadlocked over how to raise this revenue, the primary dividing point being the implementation of a sales tax. The Senate still supports a temporary general sales-tax increase and the House does not.

The ongoing divide between the two chambers has opened the door for “what if” conversations about concluding the session without the adoption of  a budget. The state’s budget for 2009-11 is already in place (i.e. the budgets that passed at the end of the 2009 session) and a supplemental budget is not required. 

These conversations, which can be recognized as still too-early conversations at this time, fail to address the state’s remaining $2.8 billion budget problem.  As you may recall, State Treasurer McIntire publicly stated earlier this year that Washington is at risk of running out of “cash” by fall 2010 without new revenues or reductions in budget expenditures. At that point, Governor Gregoire would have the authority and legal obligation to implement across-the-board cuts. An option she has been public about in the last few days but does not desire.

An across-the-board reduction of state funding is not appealing to many policymakers. It is believed that such action could be as high as 20 percent to close the $2.8 billion budget gap.   Some believe that yesterday’s move by the Senate to move Senate Bill 6143 to conference may be a small and optimistic sign towards the passage of a supplemental budget, only time will tell.

As for now, the bills needed to implement a 2010 supplemental operating budget, 2010 supplemental capital budget, and increase revenue remain where they were this weekend, with the execption of SB 6143 which has gone to conference. In addition, the bills that Evergreen is tracking this special session also have not moved further in the process.